An Open Letter to 20th Ward Residents [Updated]
The 20th Ward is diverse in so many respects, including race. Besides punishing Ald. Craig Schmid, the last redistricting was intended to create a black south side ward yet no black person has filed for the seat. Some say this is a sign blacks are content with representation from Schmid, a claim I can neither substantiate or refute.
What is without question, the aldermanic contest between incumbent Ald. Craig Schmid and Cherokee St. resident Galen Gondolfi has illustrated a major rift among the ward’s residents. Schmid has failed over the years to bring into the fold the more progressive residents. If Gondolfi wins, I think he will have issues bringing in the more conservative based of Schmid. In other words, I see the rift continuing regardless of who wins the race today.
Schmid represents the the “broken window” theory whereby you address all the small issues such as trash and broken windows which will then lead to less crime. This is a very valid approach to addressing problems but it falls short on the revitalization side. Conversely, it is a challenge to revitalze an area without employing some of the broken window strategy.
Many have tried to dismiss Gondolfi as only caring about his own personal interest of selling one of his buildings to Steve Smith, helping him get a liquor license along the way. I believe Gondolfi is approaching this from a broader perspective — what do we do with the many corner storefront properties throughout the 20th ward (and city) that are vacant or underutilized. Furthermore, what is the long-term future for commercial corridors such as Cherokee Street.
Regardless of who wins the election today, the issue of revitalizing the city’s commercial districts is a critical issue all over the city. Numerous wards have similar bans on new liquor licenses, the 20th is not alone in this issue. The conflict between long-term residents and newbies will only increase as we attract new people to our neighborhoods. Collectively we must find a way to work together.
My personal belief is we need to think less about boundaries — ward or neighborhood — and focus on commercial districts serving adjacent residents. We need to embrace diversity in terms of old & new buildings, large houses next to small flats, the staid next to the eclectic. You know, a real city. This will require all of us to look at the city through the eyes of others for whom we may not always agree. Our divisive perspectives are not serving ourselves or our city.
Again, regardless of who wins the race in the 20th (or the other races for that matter), we have considerable work to do. We need leadership to build concensus around the future of the city.
UPDATE 3/6/07 – 8:45pm
The five precints are in and Schmid has won another four years in office with 376 votes (55.46%) to Gondolfi’s 301 votes (44.40%). Given the ward’s 5,403 registered voters this is clearly not a mandate for either candidate. Schmid’s challenge now will be to bridge the divide in the ward.