Most readers don’t give change to homeless on the street
Over 250 people responded to the poll last week:
Q: When a homeless person asks you for change, do you give it to them?
- never: 143 [56.3%]
- sometimes: 87 [34.3%]
- frequently: 20 [7.9%]
- n/a — I don’t visit places where there are homeless: 4 [1.6%]
- always: 0 [0%]
Four people live sheltered lives if they don’t go where they may encounter a homeless person. The majority do not give change to the homeless. While I count myself among those who do not give change, I do give other ways. It is important to note is not every panhandler is homeless. But often the homeless do panhandle to raise money.  Here is a story of the homeless:
‘I asked what he meant and heard a story that was to be repeated to me by many people. Each person I asked told me essentially the same thing: they were ignored as if they did not exist.
A pattern began to emerge. First was the loss of work, then housing, going begging to GA (General Assistance, welfare) where they were treated like second class citizens and beggars. Not finding a bed at the shelter, they are hassled on the streets by police. Then finally they get the courage, yes I mean courage, to ask others for a little change.
A person must feel awfully low inside to have to resort to panhandling as a way of getting money for food and a place to sleep, let along clean clothes and phone change. (Bus money to look for work is about as far as GA money goes).
A person gets tired of sleeping on the streets. I know. Men are lucky to get a shelter bed once or twice a month. Women fare a little better with a couple of nights a week, but even that gets tiring. After a while you need to sleep in a real bed, have some privacy, and take a bath alone. But you do not have money for a hotel room. Where do you get the money? Your last resort, panhandling. When you begin to see what a person must go through day after day, month after month, you gain a little understanding.
But you ask what you could do.
The reason why I was not yelled at was that I acknowledged panhandlers. I let them know I knew they existed. It was not much, just a look saying that I cannot help. I would look at them, pat my pocket, and show an empty hand, or I pointed behind me with my thumb indicating I gave what I could to the last one who asked me. Sometimes I have just said “sorry.” I have also said “not this time,” “I wish I could help,” or “I just gave to the last guy.” All of which was true; I would never lie.
When I did these small things I said a lot more than my words did. I said to them, “I acknowledge you exist, I do not look down on you, you are no less a human being than I, and I respect you as a person.” All that in a gesture or a few words.
A person who is down on their luck needs a little dignity left inside. If you look, you can even see the depression in their eyes. Panhandling is their last resort as it takes the loss of a lot of self respect to do it. And courage to look someone in the face and say, “I need your help.” – Rae Chamberlain’
Acknowledging the homeless takes very little effort on my part but it means so much to them to not be ignored. Here are some other tips:
- Don’t ignore them. say hello, good afternoon or just make eye contact. It is okay to give them dignity.
- Buy What’s Up magazine (or the street newspaper in your city)
- Give money to and/or volunteer at organizations that work directly with the homeless in your community.
Resources:
An interesting way to give change is located in the Central West End:
“The Central West End Association and the City of St. Louis have announced the launch of the “Real Change” campaign. The goal of the campaign is to discourage the random giving of money to panhandlers while encouraging contributions to local social service providers. The campaign is conjuction with a new city ordinance restricting panhandling.
Parking meters donated by the St. Louis Treasurer’s Office have been installed at four locations in the Central West End. These meters will be used to collect change that will be distributed to area service providers. In addition, neighborhood businesses will distribute cards informing residents and visitors of the campaign and encouraging participation in “real change.” (Real Change program)
Homelessness continues to exist primarily in urban areas but that is changing:
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s annual survey last year found homelessness remained steady at about 1.6 million people, but the percentage of rural or suburban homelessness rose from 23 percent to 32 percent. The 2009 HUD report, which reflected the 12 months ending Sept. 30, 2008, also found the number of sheltered homeless families grew from about 473,000 to 517,000. (NY Times: Suburban Homeless: Rising Tide of Women, Families)
Suburban & rural communities need to address homelessness and the plan can’t be dropping them off at the closest urban center. Thanks to Jay Swoboda of What’s Up for his help with resources for this post.
– Steve Patterson
