A Look At Kansas City’s New Modern Streetcar

Last week leaders in the St. Louis region argued publicly over future pubic transit:

St. Louis Mayor Francis Slay has made clear his support for a north-south MetroLink expansion, saying it’s a top priority in his final year in office. But a recent push for money to plan such a route has met with strong resistance from St. Louis County Executive Steve Stenger.

Stenger, in a letter to the Federal Transit Administration, said he will not endorse the north-south route until other proposed routes are studied. (Post-Dispatch)

At the other end of the state, in Kansas City, there’s also a disagreement about the expansion of rail-based public transit. The local non-profit behind the new KC Streetcar wants to expand South on Main Street, while another is pushing a light rail plan.

[Clay] Chastain argues his plan gives Kansas City residents a real choice and a much more extensive rail transit system, from the airport to the Cerner Trails campus under construction in south Kansas City and from Union Station to the stadium complex. 

He estimates it would cost $2 billion to build, or about $45 million per mile, although some light-rail systems have cost considerably more than that per mile. He assumes the federal government would provide $1 billion of that amount.

The local match would come from a 3/8-cent sales tax increase for 25 years, plus 3/8 cents that currently go for the bus system, once that tax expires in 2024. (Kansas City Star)

Anyone who has flown in/out of KC’s airport knows it is a long distance from downtown KC. It’s a 20-25 minute drive, but takes over an hour by bus. Frankly, they need to do both — expand the new streetcar and build light rail to far off destinations like their airport and stadiums.

Kansas City was without rail-based public transit from 1957 until May 6, 2016 — the day the 2.2 mile starter streetcar opened.

THE FUNDING:

• Cost to build: $100 million — $37 million from the federal government, $63 million from bonds.
• Cost to operate: $4 million annually to be paid by a combination of sales & property taxes within the transportation district.
• Fare:  $0 — free
• Local comparison: Our Loop Trolley vintage streetcar project. also 2.2 miles long, is costing $51 million to build. The 8-mile cross-county MetroLink extension that opened in 2006 cost $430 million.

THE VEHICLES:

• “Each vehicle is 77 feet and 8 inches long; 78,000 pounds; and 12 feet tall.”
• “Each vehicle capacity is approximately 150 riders and is bi-directional (can run both directions). There is a combination of sitting and standing within the streetcar.”
• “There are three “cars” in each streetcar vehicle, with 4 sets of doors (one on each end and two in the middle car).”
• Each of the four vehicles cost $4.39 million each (source).
• Same as vehicles used in the Cincinnati Streetcar opening later this year.
• Model: CAF Urbos 3 100% low-floor
• Manufactured in Elmira NY by CAF USA, a subsidiary of a Spanish company.
• To meet US crash-standards the body is made of steel
• Comparison: our 4-car light rail vehicles are 90 feet long; capacity of 72 seated plus 106 standing

THE ROUTE:

Kansas City is lucky to have Main Street as a central arterial. We have Olive/Lindell, but they’re very different. The 2.2 mile route does a loop on the North end around their River Market area. It goes down Main and ends at Union Station.

The route is 2.2 miles long and travels along Main Street in downtown Kansas City from the River Market to Union Station/Crown Center. The route also includes a loop around the City Market and runs on 3rd St on the north, Delaware on the west, 5th St on the south, and Grand on the east. (KC Streetcar FAQ)

An extension to continue South on Main Street is already being planned.

See a route map here.

THE STOPS:

Stops are every few blocks, over the 3-day weekend I rode the streetcar a few times but also traveled the route on the sidewalk. For the most part. the stops are built out into the parking lane — leaving the sidewalk unblocked.

NEW CONSTRUCTION:

New construction is everywhere in Kansas City, especially near the streetcar route.

VIDEO:

I put together a brief video of various clips I took:

FINAL THOUGHTS:

Their streetcar isn’t meant to be a regional system, at least not initially. CAF makes very similar vehicles for use in higher-speed light rail applications, so if they ever do a light rail line the vehicles could look just like their streetcar.

The main problem we experienced was crowds — but it was a nice holiday weekend in the first month of service.  Would like to ride it on a regular weekday. We did speak to a retired couple that recently moved from the suburbs to new construction downtown — the streetcar was one reason,

Being right there it helped add life to the street. It’ll be interesting to see if they’ll be able to expand.

— Steve Patterson

Sunday Poll: Will North St. Louis Be Better Or Worse 25 Years From Now?

A quarter century ago I moved North of Delmar — from the Central West End. As I reflect back on the last 25 years, I think about what the next 25 might look like.

The National Geospatial Agency (NGA) will have been in it’s new headquarters for years. Will it help or hurt the surrounding area? Will Paul McKee’s plans get built? Will public transit be improved?

I have a lot of questions, but no crystal ball. There’s also a good chance I won’t be alive in 25 years to see the answers to my questions.

There’s no right or wrong answer to today’s poll — it’s a non-scientific measure of readers’ outlook. I’m not setting any criteria by which to compare now to 25 years from now, that’s up to you.

The poll is open until. 8pm.

Starting this week I’ll be cutting back from six posts to five — no more Monday posts, the next post will be Tuesday.

— Steve Patterson

Forest Park Dedicated June 24, 1876, 140 Years Ago Today (6 Historic Photos)

Forest Park opened 140 years ago today — nearly three decades before the 1904 World’s Fair:

Forest Park, officially opened to the public on June 24, 1876, is one of the largest urban parks in the United States. At 1,293 acres, it is approximately 500 acres larger than Central Park in New York.

In 1904, the Louisiana Purchase Exposition, The St. Louis World’s Fair, drew more than 20 million visitors from around the world to Forest Park. (St. Louis)

When Forest Park was created by the Board of Aldermen residents to the North & South also wanted large parks in their part of the city, so O’Fallon & Carondelet parks were created before Forest Park opened. At that time the parks were largely rural, a way to preserve land in a rapidly growing city.

When Forest Park officially opened to the public on Saturday afternoon, June 24, 1876, it was located in St. Louis County, almost two miles west of the St. Louis City limits and a 40 minute carriage ride from downtown. 

The Globe-Democrat reported that the opening day ceremony attracted 50,000 people — at a time when the population of the city was only 350,000.

It was on a railroad line, which had opened only a week before the park was dedicated. The train ride from downtown took 20 minutes. 

At the same time as the dedication, the Democratic Party was holding its national convention in Downtown St. Louis. (The 1870 census called St. Louis the fourth largest city in the country behind New York, Philadelphia and Brooklyn.) (St. Louis)

Yes, Forest Park was in unincorporated St. Louis County when initially dedicated. This was a good excuse for me to scan & post vintage/undated images from the archives of Louis (1907-1999) & Georgia (1918-2009) Buckowitz:

Information on the pagoda bandstand is too much for the caption:

The original Forest Park bandstand, or music pagoda, was a wooden structure that stood on an island in Pagoda Lake. It was built about the time the park was dedicated in 1876. Mary J. Rankin donated statues representing the four seasons in 1886.

The bandstand was renovated and was landscaped for the 1904 World’s Fair. It was the site of concerts before and after the fair.

However, the bandstand fell into disrepair and was declared unsafe in 1911. 

Before it could be renovated, it blew down in a storm and was damaged beyond repair. 

In July 1924, St. Louis lawyer Nathan Frank donated funds to build a new bandstand. It was designed by Heffensteller, Hirsh and Watson.

The new bandstand cost about $50,000 and is of classic Renaissance design. It is made of white marble with bronze railings and ornaments.

It was renovated in 1981 with $13,000 from the Central West End Charitable Trust, raised by the Central West End Association. 

It was renovated and landscaped by the Flora Conservancy of Forest Park under the Forest Park Master Plan. (St. Louis)

Now you know why “Pagoda Drive” is named as such. A decade until the 150th. For information on events celebrating the 140th click here.

— Steve Patterson

St. Louis Board of Aldermen: New Board Bills 6/17/16

The following new Board Bills were introduced Friday June 17, 2016:

Board Bill No. 86 | Redevelopment plan for 721 Victor

BOARD BILL NO. 86 INTRODUCED BY ALD. JOHN COATAR An ordinance approving a Redevelopment Plan for the 721 Victor St./2403-15 S. 7th St. (“Area”) after finding that the Area is blighted as defined in Section 99.320 and Chapter 353 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, 2000, as amended, (the “Statutes” being Sections 99.300 to 99.715 inclusive and Chapter 353), containing a description of the boundaries of said Area in the City of St. Louis (“City”), attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit “A”, finding that redevelopment and rehabilitation of the Area is in the interest of the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the people of the City; approving the Plan dated May 24, 2016 for the Area (“Plan”), incorporated herein by attached Exhibit “B”, pursuant to Sections 99.430 and 353.020 (4); finding that there is a feasible financial plan for the development of the Area which affords maximum opportunity for development of the Area by private enterprise; finding that no property in the Area may be acquired by the Land Clearance for Redevelopment Authority of the City of St. Louis (“LCRA”) through the exercise of eminent domain; finding that the property within the Area is unoccupied, but if it should become occupied the Redeveloper shall be responsible for relocating any eligible occupants displaced as a result of implementation of the Plan; finding that financial aid may be necessary to enable the Area to be redeveloped in accordance with the Plan; finding that there shall be available ten (10) year real estate tax abatement; and pledging cooperation of the Board of Aldermen and requesting various officials, departments, boards and agencies of the City to cooperate and to exercise their respective powers in a manner consistent with the Plan.

Board Bill No. 87 | Redevelopment plan for Kosciusko Site

BOARD BILL NO. 87 INTRODUCED BY ALDERMAN JOHN COATAR An ordinance approving a Redevelopment Plan for the Kosciusko Industrial Site I (“Area”) after finding that the Area is blighted as defined in Section 99.320 and Chapter 353 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, 2000, as amended, (the “Statutes” being Sections 99.300 to 99.715 inclusive and Chapter 353), containing a description of the boundaries of said Area in the City of St. Louis (“City”), attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit “A”, finding that redevelopment and rehabilitation of the Area is in the interest of the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the people of the City; approving the Plan dated May 24, 2016 for the Area (“Plan”), incorporated herein by attached Exhibit “B”, pursuant to Sections 99.430 and 353.020 (4); finding that there is a feasible financial plan for the development of the Area which affords maximum opportunity for development of the Area by private enterprise; finding that no property in the Area may be acquired by the Land Clearance for Redevelopment Authority of the City of St. Louis (“LCRA”) through the exercise of eminent domain; finding that the property within the Area is unoccupied, but if it should become occupied the Redeveloper shall be responsible for relocating any eligible occupants displaced as a result of implementation of the Plan; finding that financial aid may be necessary to enable the Area to be redeveloped in accordance with the Plan; finding that there shall be available up to a twenty-five (25) year real estate tax abatement; and pledging cooperation of the Board of Aldermen and requesting various officials, departments, boards and agencies of the City to cooperate and to exercise their respective powers in a manner consistent with the Plan.

Board Bill No. 88 | Ordinance regarding Traffic Calming

BOARD BILL NO. 88 INTRODUCED BY: ALDERMAN CHRIS CARTER An ordinance requiring that requests for Traffic Calming, as defined herein, and related traffic complaints, received by the City of St. Louis be managed in accordance with a centralized process to be called the City of St. Louis Traffic Calming Policy; granting the Director of Streets authority to develop and promulgate the City of St. Louis Traffic Calming Policy, subject to the Board of Public Service approval; containing an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 89 | Amending Civil Service Ordinance

BOARD BILL NO. 89 INTRODUCED BY: ALDERMAN FRANK WILLIAMSON An ordinance to amend Ordinance 70285 by removing Section 29 of Ordinance 70285, providing an effective date and including an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 90 | Ordinance establishing 3-way stop at Marquette & Prather

BOARD BILL NO. 90 INTRODUCED BY ALDERMAN JOSEPH VACCARO An Ordinance establishing a three-way stop site at the intersection of Marquette Avenue and Prather Avenue by regulating all eastbound and westbound traffic traveling on Marquette Avenue at Prather Avenue and regulating all northbound traffic traveling on Prather Avenue at Marquette Avenue, and containing an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 91 | Vacation of Barton & 7th Street

BOARD BILL #91 INTRODUCED BY: ALDERMAN JACK COATAR An ordinance recommended by the Board of Public Service to conditionally vacate above surface, surface and sub-surface rights for vehicle, equestrian and pedestrian travel in 17 foot wide north/south alley in City Block 840 as bounded by Barton St., 7th St., Victor St. and 9th St. in the City of St. Louis, Missouri, as hereinafter described, in accordance with Charter authority, and in conformity with Section l4 of Article XXI of the Charter and imposing certain conditions on such vacation.

Board Bill No. 92 | Vacation of N/S alley at Terrance/Christy

BOARD BILL #92 INTRODUCED BY: ALDERWOMAN BETH MURPHY An ordinance recommended by the Board of Public Service to conditionally vacate above surface, surface and sub-surface rights for vehicle, equestrian and pedestrian travel in 17.5 foot wide north/south alley in City Block 5334 from Terrace Ave. south 150.07 feet to the 15 foot wide east/west alley in City Block 5334 as bounded by Terrace Ave., Christy Blvd.. Gravois Ave. and Dahlia Ave. in the City of St. Louis, Missouri, as hereinafter described, in accordance with Charter authority, and in conformity with Section l4 of Article XXI of the Charter and imposing certain conditions on such vacation.

Board Bill No. 93 | Ordinance authorizing Parcel Development Agreement

BOARD BILL # 93 INTRODUCED BY ALDERWOMAN TAMMIKA HUBBARD An Ordinance recommended by the Board of Estimate and Apportionment authorizing the execution of a Parcel Development Agreement by and among The City of St. Louis, Missouri, Northside Regeneration, LLC, and St. Louis Grocery Real Estate, LLC; prescribing the form and details of said Parcel Development Agreement; authorizing certain actions by City officials; and containing a severability clause.

Board Bill No. 94 | 4-way stop at Walsh & Clifton

BOARD BILL NO. 94 INTRODUCED BY ALDERWOMAN DONNA BARINGER An Ordinance establishing a four-way stop site at the intersection of Walsh Street and Clifton Avenue by regulating all eastbound and westbound traffic traveling on Walsh Street at Clifton Avenue and regulating all northbound and southbound traffic traveling on Clifton Avenue at Walsh Street, and containing an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 95 |Ordinance prohibiting the installation of any new pole signs

BOARD BILL NO. 95 INTRODUCED BY: ALDERWOMAN SHARON TYUS An ordinance prohibiting the installation of any new pole signs, any sandwich signs, limiting signage to one sign attached to the building and establishing a closing time of 7:00 p.m., for all businesses located on Kingshighway Memorial Boulevard, containing an exception, and containing an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 96 | Ordinance to close traffic at Wabada west of Union

BOARD BILL NO. 96 INTRODUCED BY ALDERWOMAN SHARON TYUS An Ordinance amending Ordinance 70238 directing the Director of Streets to permanently close barricade or otherwise impede the flow of Traffic at Wabada 75 feet east the west curb line of Union Boulevard and containing an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 97 | Ordinance to close traffic at Terry & Kingshighway

BOARD BILL NO. 97 INTRODUCED BY ALDERWOMAN SHARON TYUS An Ordinance amending Ordinance 70224 directing the Director of Streets to permanently close barricade or otherwise impede the flow of Traffic at Terry Avenue at the west curb line of Kingshighway Memorial Boulevard and containing an emergency clause.

Board Bill No. 98 | Ordinance pertaining to court fees

BOARD BILL NO. 98 INTRODUCED BY ALDERMAN JEFFREY BOYD An Ordinance pertaining to miscellaneous fees or surcharges imposed by the City Courts; amending Section Two of Ordinance 56787, codified as Section 3.08.240 of the Revised Code of the City of St. Louis, by providing for the assessment of a four dollar ($4.00) fee imposed by the City Courts for payment of court costs by means other than cash or negotiable instrument in order to cover the transaction costs imposed by credit card companies or other payment providers and containing an emergency clause.

Video of the meeting, which includes “perfection” of BB64 (starts at 1:03:50) :

— Steve Patterson

Absentee Voting Begins Today for August 2nd Primary

Absentee voting for the Missouri’s August 2nd primary begins today. Since the St. Louis region has too many units of government to list all races/candidates, I’m focusing on the ballot voters in the City of St. Louis will face.

My list here differs slightly from the sample ballot:

1. I’ve omitted races with only a single candidate
2. Races listed here are in reverse order, though candidates are still in ballot order for their respective race.

If you read this in the order presented you’ll see smaller parties/races first.

At this point I’m endorsing in only three races, all on the Democratic Ballot:

• Megan Betts for Committeewoman 5th Ward
• Rasheen Aldridge for Committeeman 5th Ward
• Bruce Franks for State Rep. District 78

All three are challenging Rodney or Penny Hubbard. I know all three personally and have donated a small amount to each campaign. We recently hosted a meet & greet for them.

Below are challenged races in the August 2nd partisan primary:

GREEN PARTY

FOR TREASURER

• JEROME BAUER
• DON DE VIVO

LIBERTARIAN PARTY

FOR U.S. SENATOR

REPUBLICAN PARTY

FOR U.S. REP. DISTRICT 1

• STEVEN G. BAILEY
• PAUL BERRY III

FOR ATTORNEY GENERAL

• JOSH HAWLEY
• KURT SCHAEFER

FOR SECRETARY OF STATE

• WILL KRAUS
• JOHN (JAY) ASHCROFT
• ROI CHINN

FOR LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR:

• ARNIE C. – AC DIENOFF
• BEV RANDLES
• MIKE PARSON

FOR GOVERNOR

• CATHERINE HANAWAY
• ERIC GREITENS
• JOHN BRUNNER
• PETER D. KINDER

DEMOCRATIC PARTY

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 27

• PAMELA BOYD
• RACHEL JOHNS

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 27

• NATHAN BOYD
• CHRIS CARTER
• JIMMIE MATTHEWS

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 26

• TISHAURA O, JONES
• KARLA MAY

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 26

• JOSEPH (JOE) PALM
• DONALD L. GAGE II

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 22

• NORMA J. WALKER
• ANNIE MILDRED COOPER

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 21

• ABDUL-KABA ABDULLAH
• JAMES A. KEYS

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 20

• KEMATA K. MCCLINE
• WENDY CAMPBELL

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 20

• GLENN BURLEIGH
• DALE SWEET

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 19

• CLINT HARRIS
• RICHARD R. WILSON

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 14

• MADALINE BUTHOD
• LAURA OWENS

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 11

• ADAM KUSTRA
• JACOB W. HUMMEL

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 10

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 10

• ROB STELZER
• MAX ROBERT CASSILLY

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 9

• PAT ORTMANN
• SARA JOHNSON

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 8

• ANNIE RICE
• NORAH J. RYAN

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 8

• TONY ZEBROWSKI
• PAUL F. FEHLER

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 7

• MARTY (JOE) MURRAY, JR
• BRIAN ANTHONY WAHBY

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 6

• MARY ENTRUP
• ALISON DREITH

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 6

• MATTHEW CARROLL-SCHMIDT
• MICHAEK BUTLER

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 5

• PENNY V. HUBBARD
• MEGAN BETTS (endorsed)

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 5

• RODNEY HUBBARD
• RASHEEN ALDRIDGE (endorsed)

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 4

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 3

• LUCINDA FRAZIER
• MARGUERITE DILLWORTH
• SHEILA RENDON

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 3

• ANTHONY BELL
• BRANDON BOSLEY

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 2

• JOYCE M. HALL
• LISA MIDDLEBROOK

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 2

• LARRY MIDDLEBROOK
• DAVID [DA] MOSLEY

FOR COMMITTEEWOMAN WARD 1

• MANDA DAVIS
• RAQUEL GANT
• YOLANDA [GLASS] BROWN

FOR COMMITTEEMAN WARD 1

• AZIM AZIZ
• STERLING SAMUEL MILLER

FOR SHERIFF

• JOSEPH [JOE] VACCARO
• VERNON BETTS
• JOHNNIE CHESTER, SR.
• CHARLEY [BIG WILL] WILLIAMS
• JIMMIE MATTHEWS

FOR CIRCUIT ATTORNEY

• KIMBERLY M. GARDNER
• PATRICK HAMMACHER
• STEVE HARMON
• MARY PAT CARL

STATE REP. DISTRICT 81

• ALFRED J. (FRED) WESSELS
• STEVE BUTZ
• ADAM KUNSTRA

STATE REP. DISTRICT 80

• BEN MURRAY
• PETER MERIDETH

FOR STATE REP. DISTRICT 78

• BRUCE FRANKS (endorsed)
• PENNY V, HUBBARD

FOR STATE REP. DISTRICT 77

• JESSE TODD
• STEVE ROBERTS
• JOHN COLLINS-MUHAMMAD
• BRIAN ELSESSER

FOR STATE REP. DISTRICT 66

• TOMMIE PIERSON, JR.
• KHALIL ABDUL MUMIN
• MARLENE TERRY

FOR STATE SENATOR DISTRICT 5

• JAMILAH NASHEED
• DYLAN HASSINGER

FOR U.S. REP. DISTRICT 1

• (WILLIAM) BILL HASS
• LACY CLAY
• MARIA N. CHAPPELLE-NADAL

FOR ATTORNEY GENERAL:

• JAKE ZIMMERMAN
• TERESA HENSLEY

FOR STATE TREASURER

• PAT CONTRERAS
• JUDY BAKER

FOR SECRETARY OF STATE

• BILL CLINTON YOUNG
• ROBIN SMITH
• MD RABBI ALAM

FOR LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR

• WINSTON APPLE
• RUSS CARNAHAN
• TOMMIE PIERSON, SR.

FOR GOVERNOR

• LEONARD JOSEPH STEINMAN II
• CHRIS KOSTER
• ERIC MORRISON
• CHARLES B. WHEELER

FOR U.S. SENATOR

• CHIEF WANA DUBIE
• CORI BUSH
• JASON KANDER
• ROBERT MACK

Whether you vote at the polls or via absentee ballot, please research the races/candidates in your ward/district.

Not registered yet? You’ve got until July 6th.

— Steve Patterson