Home » Featured »Planning & Design »Popular Culture » Currently Reading:

Poll: Should New LGBT Businesses Locate Within The Grove “Gayborhood” or Elsewhere?

January 22, 2012 Featured, Planning & Design, Popular Culture 29 Comments

One debate often heard in cities is about gayborhoods, or gay village. Let’s start by defining this term which may be new to many of you, from Wikipedia:

A gay village (also known as a gay neighborhood, gay district) is an urban geographic location with generally recognized boundaries where a large number of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people live or frequent. Gay villages often contain a number of gay-oriented establishments, such as gay bars and gay pubs, nightclubs, bathhouses, restaurants, and bookstores.

Such areas may represent a gay-friendly oasis in an otherwise hostile city, or may simply have a high concentration of gay residents and/or businesses. Much as other urbanized groups, some gay men and women have managed to utilize their spaces as a way to reflect gay cultural value and serve the special needs of individuals in relation to society at large.

Typically, today, these neighborhoods can be found in the upscale or trendy parts of town, chosen for aesthetic or historic value, no longer resulting from the sociopolitical ostracization and the constant threat of physical violence from homophobic individuals that originally motivated the homosexual communities to live together for their mutual safety.

However, these neighborhoods are also often found in working-class parts of the city, or in the neglected fringe of a downtown area – communities which may have been upscale historically but became economically depressed and socially disorganized. In these cases, the establishment of a gay community may eventually turn these areas into more expensive neighborhoods, a process known as gentrification – a phenomenon in which gays often play a pioneer role. However, this process does not always work out to the benefit of queer communities, as they often see property values rise so high that they can no longer afford them as high rise condominiums are built and gay bars move out. (Or the only gay establishments that remain are those catering to a more upscale clientele.)

Today’s manifestations of gay “ghettos” bear little resemblance to those of the 1970s.

In St. Louis today the gayborhood is The Grove on Manchester Ave. In the 21+ years I’ve lived in St. Louis the location of the gay village has moved around a bit, although this is the first time in my memory that we’ve had such a concentration in one area. Many feel empowered by such a strong presence and want to continue that direction.

Enter Hamburger Mary’s, a franchise of the small gay-friendly chain that originated in San Francisco.

ABOVE: You can't miss Hamburger Mary's on Olive. Click to view website.

I’ve heard some who are upset Hamburger Mary’s is on Olive in the Midtown Alley area rather than be grouped with other LGBT-friendly establishments in The Grove. For me the location on Olive is more convenient but I see the other side of the argument too.  I want to know your thoughts on the subject so this question is the poll this week. The poll is in the right sidebar.

- Steve Patterson

  • Dani9503

    I think this is a great location for Hamburger Mary’s.  I think by putting it in a more “mainstream”, up-and-coming area is rather smart for a variety of reasons: 1. It’s close to a college campus thus increasing the daily income potential (it won’t necessarily just be a night spot), 2. potential patrons who may be otherwise “intimidated” by a gayborhood would possibly come to eat here, thus increasing their gay comfort and increasing likelihood of visiting the Strip, and 3. the location is pretty convenient.  But that area is also pretty hit-or-miss for businesses, so I guess we’ll have to see…

  • http://twitter.com/Torcho A Torch

    Isn’t this good that we are getting away from segregating groups of minorities? You start out with pockets so you can build an alliance and feel empowered and then hopefully the ignorant will learn they have nothing to fear, and then the businesses blend in with all that surround. I like the idea of breaking down barriers in STL…..about 50 years lagging.

  • Anonymous

    I said it before, I’ll say it again, labels are dangerous.  Either we’re going to be an inclusive society or we’re going to continue to be segregated.  It doesn’t matter if you or I self-segregate or we label (and distance ourselves from) groups of people that we see as somehow “different”.  In Hamburger Mary’s case, I’m seeing more of a marketing gimmic than anything else, much like the Hard Rock Cafe or Buca-di-Beppo.

    For most business owners, the only color that really matters is green.  If attracting more of one segment of society offsets the losses incurred by discouraging other segments, then go for it, just don’t expect the LBGT community to be any less fickle than the larger community out there.  And BTW, how’s the parking?  Will they have valet available?  Gimmics only go so far . . . .

  • http://urbanreviewstl.com/ Steve Patterson

    The effort to concentrate in The Grove is fairly recent. LGBT businesses still exist elsewhere such as South Grand, on Euclid in the CWE and in Soulard.

  • RobbyD

    Please don’t tell me that this folks on this forum are ready to do away with the “Italian” Hill neighborhood or “Irish” Dogtown neighborhood…Labels that arise out people or individuals expressing their identity is not only a good thing, it’s necessary to competently talk about reality…Those labels that arise out of hateful intentions to disparage others is obviously problematic…

  • Anonymous

    “labels that arise out of hateful intentions to disparage others is obviously problematic”.  Absolutely.  The problem is that many labels cut both ways, most obviously in the black / white divide that colors many issues in the St. Louis region.  Italians and Irish may self select, as do many Bosnians and Hispanics, and as do white supremicists and black nationalists.  We all have our histories and we all have our characteristics that HELP to define each of us.  The nuance is the help to part – once you accept that you are solely or primarily “X”, you have created a divide between yourself and the larger society.  And whether or not that is “hateful” depends on who you’re talking to or with. 

    The N word gets tossed around freely among younger members of the black community, but god forbid that a white person use it in civilized conversation.  You can open a gay-friendly, black-oriented or smoke-free businesses and be considered PC.  Try doing the opposite and be prepared for significnt blowback.  I embrace diversity, but there needs to be a level playing field.  if we can’t discriminate equally and “fairly”, the only solution is to move beyond the labels that create the discrimination in the first place.  Or, to put it another way, I really don’t care if Steve is gay, disabled or an okie, I only care that he is passionate and articulate about urban design issues in the region.  Until a significant portion of the white community here moves beyond equating black with crime and poverty, we’re going to be stuck with vast swaths of our community decaying and dying.

  • Fozzie

    Chain restaurants are not neighborhood-friendly!

  • samizdat

    Somebody should be shot for painting that building pink…along with the one at Sarah(?) and Vandeventer–the bar.

    Really, what idiot thinks Pepto-Bismol is a good color to paint a building, much less a brick one?

  • http://twitter.com/frusaurus Will Fru

    I’m not sure I would consider the Grove the prime “gayborhood” in town.  Yes, the lion’s share of the gay bars are there, as well as the new location of the Center, but in residential terms, I think (based on anecdote and experience) there isn’t as great a concentration of queer residents in the Grove as in the CWE or especially Tower Grove and Soulard.

  • http://twitter.com/frusaurus Will Fru

    Put another way, the Grove is the gayborhood after 9pm on weekends.  The rest of the week, the gay population does most of their living elsewhere.

  • Anonymous

    Someone who wants to attract attention!

    And while I know you’re being sarcastic, “Somebody should be shot for painting that building pink” is fighting words.  I agree, painting brick is stupid.  But if you’re saying that you have the right to be a design vigilante (for the choice of pink), you’ve gone too far.  Paint is temporary, it can and wil be replaced.  If you want the city or some homeowner’s association telling you which shade of beige to use, move to the ‘burbs!

  • Anonymous

    Because why?  They have money to invest?  They’re willing to move into vacant retail space?  They’ll be hiring local workers?  They have a proven track record?  They offer a predicatable product?  They’ll attract customers?  They have no “soul”?  Their profits won’t stay local?

    Chain restaurants include everything from Dewey’s to Pizza Hut, Hamburger Mary’s to Burger King, Lion’s Choice to Arby’s, the St. Louis Bread Company to Subway.  Some chains are obviously better than others.  To say that every chain restaurant is bad is just as disingenuous as saying that every individually-owned establishment is the best thing that could ever happen to any neighborhood corner.  There are good owners and bad owners, good managers and bad managers. 

    If a chain comes to an established neighborhood and plays by the rules, why should they be excluded?  Why, in the Delmar Loop, are Chipotle, Noodles & Co. and Snarf’s “bad” and Cheesology and the Gyro House “good”?  Explain how having only one location is inherently better than having two, six or a thousand?  The customers will ultimately decide whether any one location succeeds or fails, and few will care how many other locations are somewhere else on this planet!

  • Stacy

    Chain restaurants are not neighbourhood friendly, especially ones owned by hostile gays. Gays are not friendly to the environment and to the success of St. Louis. 

  • Anonymous

    Please elaborate.

  • Mike

    I often overhear my teenage son and daughter talking with their friends. If the issue of “gay or lesbian” comes up, it is regarded as a point of information vs. a judgment on the particular lifestyle. It’s great that this generation is so openminded and non-judgmental. I sense that in 10 years,it won’t matter where “gay businesses” are located. They’ll be viewed no differently than “straight” businesses for the most part. There are obviously exceptions (certain gay bookstores/arcades, gay bathhouses, etc), but there is no particular reason why most gay-owned business  must locate in a gay district.

  • Matt Herron

    I’m Matt Herron with Scottrade Compliance.  I am a little fruity and like the smell of feet.  Just wanted to let ya all know!  Sweet, sweaty feet turn me on.

  • Matt Herron

    I’m Matt Herron with Scottrade Compliance.  I am a little fruity and like the smell of feet.  Just wanted to let ya all know!  Sweet, sweaty feet turn me on.

  • Moe

    Panera, aka St. Louis Bread  Co. started as a local business, now a top 50 restaurant chain in the USA.  Should we boycott because they are a chain or patronize them because they are local?  And they are still local…their headquarters is in Sunset Hills. 
    In my opinion, it is the management that makes a chain a good neighbor, not the name above the door and not the food coming in as both get their food from the same sources.

  • Investor

    Hamburger Mary’s St. Louis is not owned by “hostile gays.”  The investor group members are all St. Louis residents. Some of the investors are straight, some are gay, some are male, some are female, some are young, some are older. It is a very diverse group, much like the customers we hope will enjoy coming to our restaurant. The profits made will stay in St. Louis because we all live here, and we believe in investing in this wonderful city and trying to make it better for all.  

  • Fozzie

    Steve laments chains in one post, yet in the same week welcomes another.  I’m sorry sarcasm is hard to detect in cyberspace.

  • Anonymous

    I don’t think he was so much welcoming Hamburger Mary’s so much as he was noting that it is a gay establishment (which happens to be a national chain) that’s not opening in the Gay Village of The Grove. 

  • samizdat

    “Gays are not friendly to the environment and to the success of St. Louis.”

    What a load of shite.

  • samizdat

    I default to a saying my wife attributes to her mother: “All of their taste is in their mouth”.  Frankly I’m not one of those hyper-sensitive property-rights nutjobs. If you want to do something on your property, and it offends, pollutes, or damages in any way, you should expect some criticism…and in the case with pollution, legal action. Shit, you pussies, if you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.

    Hell, Jim, at least I don’t go around repeating lies about asbestos as if I’m a fucking shill for W.R. Grace, et al.

  • http://urbanreviewstl.com/ Steve Patterson

    In my experience suburban municipalities and home owners associations can be just as limiting/controlling as the big bad inner city. It’s false to suggest otherwise.

  • Anonymous

    That was my point – the suburbs are way more limiting than the city when it comes to design standards.  Unless a building is in a historic district, the city is more concerned that a building is painted (no peeling paint) than in what color(s) it may be.

  • Anonymous

    Huh?  Where did asbestos enter the discusssion?

    And, to quote, “Frankly I’m not one of those hyper-sensitive property-rights nutjobs. If you want to do something on your property, and it offends, pollutes, or damages in any way, you should expect some criticism” and “somebody should be shot for painting that building pink”.  There’s a big jump between “some criticism” and “somebody should be shot”. 

    Sarcasm is harder to convey in print than it is face-to-face, which is why I began my original response with “I know you’re being sarcastic”.  The problem is words need to be taken a face value.  If you had said the owner should have been cited or sued, there would be less baggage, especially when we live in a violent city, one where one can and does get shot for much, much less (like a hamburger).  Advocating for violence does nothing to further the discussion.

    Which gets back to the original point, that you don’t like buildings painted Pepto-Bismol pink.  What colors do you like?  Shades of beige?  Deep accents?  Pure white?  Solid black?  Primary colors?  Metallics?  And if you don’t like a color choice, what recourse should you have?  Just bitching about it?  Getting the city involved, with some sort of design review?  Suing the owners and/or tenants for bad taste and/or emotional distress?

    It’s hard to have minimal design review, you either have none or you have total review.  I choose to live in a city with no real design review since I don’t want to live in one with stringent regulations, since stringent requlations almost always equals “safe”, bland and boring.  Creativity happens on the edges, not in the safe middle.  Will you sometimes get bad, ugly results?  Absolutely!  But you’ll also get quirky, unusual, even cutting-edge solutions – you gotta take the bad with the good.

  • Branwell1

    I suspect a troll provocateur hereabout. Dig the spelling of “neighbourhood”! Jolly good! Are we to assume we have a Brit critic in the house who doesn’t want the bloody ponces mucking up Manchester for all the downhome Andy Capps who fancy a pint of wholesomeness unbesmirched by proximity of buggery?? 

  • RyleyinSTL

    What exactly is a LGBT friendly business and why does it need to be in a special part of town?  Do the “gays” like their coffee just a bit more strong than I do and prefer that their local shop know this without requiring that they ask for it?

    Its not 1950 anymore, I would think that LGBT money is just as good as cranky old white man money at any business.  No need for segregated commercial districts or special LGBT shops is there?  The only people left discriminating against LGBT folks are dinosaurs like bed shitters and backwards Christians.

  • MAKES_SENSE_DONT_DO_IT

    Seems like everyone is okay with Hamburger Mary’s in Midtown Alley.  Come down and give it a try.  Food is great at moderate prices and there are lots of things to see and do.  Locally owned and operated.  Only one location per city. 

Advertisement


Related Posts

Readers: LGBT-Friendly Establishments Shouldn’t Be Pressured To Locate In The Gayborhood

1 Feb 2012

(12 Comments)

Intersection of Chouteau, Vandeventer & Manchester is Bleak

19 Jan 2012

(8 Comments)

Readers: Open Streets is a Good Idea

19 Oct 2011

(3 Comments)

Delayed Reduction of Lanes on Manchester Delayed Safety Benefits of Road Diet

11 Jul 2011

(11 Comments)

Archives

Categories

Recent Comments

National Partner


  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
order Crestor no visa online purchase Zovirax buy Bupropion on line amex buy Amitriptyline online now i want to buy Prednisone without a perscription buy Zithromax without prescription generic Maxalt usa buy discount Prednisone buy Flomax money buy buy cheap generic Cytotec order Flomax usa cod buy Flomax with a mastercard order Strattera online with overnight delivery buy Cytotec without a perscription purchase online Strattera without prescription Proscar overnight no consult buy Proscar pills best buy Valtrex Zithromax cash on delivery buy finpecia online overseas purchase cheap online prednisone purchase Prednisone without prescription to ship overnight order no prescription Valtrex buy valtrex free consultation purchase Valtrex without buy Prednisone cash on delivery uk buy Prednisone where can i buy Proscar without prescription order valtrex usa buy Maxalt without a credit card buy Cytotec without doctor discount prednisone overnight order cheapest online prednisone buy Flomax cheap online Cytotec purchased online without prescription Cytotec without prescription overnight shipping buy Proscar online with a debit card purchase Buspar cod overnight delivery buy Zithromax visa buy Maxalt how to order Valtrex online without prescription finpecia without rx medications buying Valtrex buy in Flomax uk Cipro without prescription buy Cytotec c o d how to buy Proscar online without rx Cytotec overnight cod buy valtrex online no prescription cheap generic valtrex buy Crestor offshore no prescription fedex Crestor best buy order Zithromax cheap overnight discount Zithromax uk Zithromax generic where can i purchase Prednisone online Valtrex shipped cash on purchase Crestor pay pal online without prescription buy Crestor where buy brand Crestor prednisone with consult Buspar online purchase ordering Strattera over the counter cheap Strattera no rx buy cheap generic Buspar free Buspar Crestor without prescription medications Orlistat non prescription for next day delivery Arimidex delivered overnight order prednisone without prescription to ship overnight order overnight Crestor safety order prednisone purchase Tamsulosin pay pal without rx where to buy Flomax without a prescription Flomax with repronex buy Flomax online without prescription wholesale Flomax cheap buy cheapest Flomax and Flomax Tamsulosin order online order generic Flomax purchase Crestor no scams proscar cheap overnight fedex proscar without prescription purchase proscar cod overnight delivery buying Antabuse over the counter Valtrex online no rx overnight buy generic Valtrex pills order Orlistat no visa buy online prednisone without rx purchase Valtrex no prescription cheap buy cheapest Cipro Crestor no prescription to buy purchase Valtrex paypal without prescription purchase rx Crestor without Valtrex online buy Valtrex doctor prescription Valtrex online Orlistat from india buy genuine Orlistat online buy cod Arimidex buy Rosuvastatin with american express purchase cheap Cytotec How to buy valtrex online without a perscription online pharmacy valtrex buy Cytotec online without a prescription purchasing prednisone with overnight delivery where can i buy herbal Buspar how to order Zithromax online without prescription where can i purchase Zithromax no rx buy herbal Finpecia buy xenical no script buy Buspar with visa purchase Buspar no prescription cheap buy xenical online without a prescription and no membership buspar online no perscription fedex buy valtrex online without a prescription buy Valtrex ukbuy Valtrex amex online without rx buy generic finpecia online purchase finpecia overnight finpecia to buy no prescription Valtrex what is finpecia cheap generic Orlistat buy Orlistat drugs buy finpecia cash on delivery where to purchase generic Prednisone online without a rx order cheapest online Buspar buy line Orlistat online prescription Valtrex generic indian valtrex buy Proscar cheap online purchase accutane 40 mg without prescription from us pharmacy order buy accutane 40 mg online purchase Cytotec thyroxine no scams purchase Proscar without prescription to ship overnight buy Valtrex online cod buy Buspar on line amex best Buspar online pill Buspar prices prescription Buspar